<noframes id="bhbxf">

    <address id="bhbxf"></address>
    <sub id="bhbxf"></sub>
      <address id="bhbxf"></address>

      <address id="bhbxf"><address id="bhbxf"><menuitem id="bhbxf"></menuitem></address></address>

      <noframes id="bhbxf">
      當前位置:首頁 > 資訊信息 > 新聞動態 > 詳細信息
      學術期刊同行評議是與非
      來源: | 作者: | 發布時間:2015-9-12 16:39:31

      近年來,無論學術界還是期刊界,有關同行評議的話題從未中斷過。3月31日,在由中國人民大學主辦、中國人民大學書報資料中心和中國人民大學人文社會科學學術成果評價研究中心承辦的“人文社會科學學術成果評價發布論壇”上,與會專家、學者圍繞同行評議在學界、期刊界的熱點、難點等話題展開討論,以期為學術評價標準和體系的建設擴展思路。

          “老千里馬選小千里馬”局面應改觀

          學術界此前總在說“同行承認是學界的‘硬通貨’”,但在中國科學院學部學科發展戰略研究中心主任劉益東看來,這只說對了一半。同行評議對于問世時間較長的成果是有效的,而對問世不久的成果,特別是問世不久的獨創性成果卻是低效率的,往往是非共識的,有時還形成了“不是伯樂選千里馬,而是老千里馬選小千里馬”的局面。

          武漢大學中國科學評價研究中心主任邱均平認為,人文社會科學同行評議有其特殊性和復雜性。以期刊審稿為例,很多期刊并未建立起規范的同行評議程序,審稿、選稿和用稿還顯得較為隨意。

          北京大學圖書館文獻計量學研究室原主任蔡蓉華對此表示認同。她認為,人們由于時間、精力、財力的限制,不得不有選擇地利用,有選擇地評價。但由于科學評價的復雜性,評價結果往往難以令人滿意,因此經常會遭到非議。并且,評價標準和程序機械化,也難以保護創新思維,影響合理評價,進而影響到學術期刊對學術新成果的展示。

          讓大數據在評價體系中發揮作用

          在談到大數據時代同行評議的實踐時,邱均平表示,大數據環境下的信息采集與傳統的同行評議相比,數據量的增加、數據類型的豐富能從更多方面強化定量分析的精確性、穩定性,數據信息的深度挖掘更提高了計量指標的有效性。同時,還可以增加專家對對象的了解,可以支持交叉學科、支持創新,可以建立完善的專家數據庫,通過隨機方式篩選合適的同行,破解學科限制和學術壟斷,更可以提高同行評價的效率、降低成本。

          “通過公開實現公平、公正,通過公開實現高效合理顯得尤為重要,而這些在網絡時代是有實現基礎的。開放式的評價可以基本做到以創新論英雄、以突破論英雄,讓優秀人才脫穎而出并發揮作用。”劉益東說。

          與此同時,中國社會科學院學部委員黃長著也提醒道,網絡環境下的量化評價雖然相對客觀、操作便捷,但由于指標體系的復雜性,在確定各項指標的分值時易受到研制者本身偏好和認知能力的限制。

          體系建設在驗證中完善和發展

          在我國近6000種學術期刊中,水平參差不齊,發展并不平衡,如果不能建立全面、客觀、公正并且反映我國學術期刊實際狀況的評價體系,就難以真正把期刊評價轉化為一種激勵機制。

          蔡蓉華認為,引入網絡同行評議并不是一勞永逸的。雖然開放獲取同行評議和公眾評議能縮短評議周期,突破地理和專業限制,實現評議過程和結果的網上查詢,提高了公開和公正程度,但其有效性、可靠性和其他網絡資源一樣也存在著問題,還有待研究解決。

          “任何評價機制都不會是完美無瑕的,無論選擇哪種方式都會存在這樣那樣的缺陷,評價機構應該根據評價目的和客觀條件選擇合適的評價方法,才能取得比較理想的評價結果。”蔡蓉華補充道。

          黃長著也認同這樣的觀點,他認為,要探索包括同行專家主導下融入多項指標在內的綜合評價指標體系,通過實踐反復驗證,在驗證中不斷完善,在完善中求得新的發展。

      中國新聞出版網

      256彩票 www.52303w.com | www.68993253.com | 8030c.com | www.66332c.com | www.5911o.com | www.576590.com | www.16297766.com | 1384.com | www.47506h.com | 4340e.com | www.871453.com | www.1869o.com | emz7995.com | www.109439.com | 1104016.com | www.00797a.com | 83086c.com | www.629683.com | www.480455c.com | 2267z.com | www.6699nsb.com | pj677f.com | www.657069.com | www.j99888.com | 37688k.com | www.23579b.com | www.benz4411s.com | 1591eee.com | www.98698i.com | 1yi.com | www.am7979.com | www.hg2425.com | 59599b.com | www.087s.com | www.365635.com | b987.xyz | www.323195.com | ff555j.com | buyu981.com | www.6hg6668.com | a757011.com | www.am2220.com | www.35138.com | 8898222.com | www.78949c.com | www.995v.net | 3189.com | www.9818w.cc | www.853789.com | ff7742.com | www.878zf.com | www.hg151.com | 53262t.com | www.548211.com | www.85857f.com | 35442.com | www.599464.com | www.99113r.com | 8547c.com | www.257512.com | www.3983119.com | 7979xpj.com | 7773657.com | 官网捕鱼3.com | www.606920.com | www.85857j.com | 5019333.com | www.630958.com | www.cai51.com | mm99966.com | www.238500.com | www.y69096.com | 3018pp.com | 2418c.com | www.180662.com | www.25288i.com | 30524.com | www.701250.com | www.4963j.com | hh5443.com | 97799m.com | www.t639.com | www.70022.com | 3957p.com | www.452817.com | www.85155.com | www.85770g.com | 36400033.com | www.923633.com | www.d5669.com | jinlong12.com | 61789k.com | www.39500g.com | www.hg7695.com | 3523.net | 0270098.com | www.15259.cc | www.e92776.com | www.81866r.com | 1305009.com | www.890413.com | www.068wy.com | 2546s.com | 22207q.com | www.hm5333.com | www.bwinyz32.com | www.653508.com | rrr5144.com | www.620477.com | www.744363.com | www.58777j.com | 86811bb.com | yk802.com | www.3005x.com | www.3116p.com | www.30309193.com | 4182000.com | 88904141.com | www.99714.cc | www.4078j.com | www.4972vv.com | ff67890.com | 228888x.com | www.68682q.com | www.n456x.com | www.pj550055.com | hhgz0077.com | 5295o.com | www.den00.com | www.9895n.com | www.0009193.com | 8557t.com | 667766u.com | www.602434.com | www.456369.net | www.kzcs4.com | www.88hggj.com | 4025y.com | 62222y.com | www.2875e.com | www.47506q.com | www.bh99o.com | k83377.com | acp0006.com | v997a.com | www.0014y.com | www.2021t.com | www.4519.com | www.55574.vip | 73hg.com | 8a8u.com | 50000997.com | www.743966.com | www.4331c.com | www.16181q.com | www.pj5506.com | 8290z.com | youfa560.com | 2418c.com | www.160913.com | www.7782y.com | www.742588.com | www.2302325.com | www.00618m.com | 2381002.com | 92266z.com | 125588.com | www.233896.com | www.3552d.com | www.52062m.com | www.ff55826.com | www.pj663388.com | www.hg158.ag | 3544i.com | 28288ww.com | jsjlb9.com | 88051.com | www.107658.com | www.hx1114.com | www.96386n.com | www.566733.com | www.kzcs4.com | www.js13777.com | www.1133hg.com | 69441166.com | 2140011.com | 11005g.com | 500000631.com | 4379k.com | 83378w.com | www.551727.com | www.qmfc7.com | www.35155x.com | www.693377.com | www.377666m.com | www.5504g.com | www.hg7660.com | www.320288.com | www.hg2218.com | feicai0410.com | 56744.com | 4370.com | 896288.com | 39390524.com | 0008.io | hfgszc580.com | 175080.com | 829330.com | 55818d.com | 38238a | www.055972.com | 3513001.com | k3405.com | www.jsh110.com | wb130.com | a32355.com | laok222.com | hgbet.com | 5651a.com | n5429.com | 20182013.com | hccy365.com | 8970399.com | 48285555.com | 5478a.com | hb7.com | xin98886.com | 3568p.com | 86611u.com | 9479c3.com | 6269ee.com | 81366s.com | x3456.com | 6613633.com | 17790000.com | s77304.com | 9479a3.com | 53262ee.com | 4036222.com | pp3405.com | 112x.net | 2267c.com | 51335w.com | 033i.net | www.10899f.com | www.77164.com | www.44992055.com | www.771671c.com | www.xj666q.com | www.11557.com | www.jz9788.com | www.80188v.com | www.44118a.com | www.0343n.com | www.159433.com | www.34489.cc | www.817336.com | www.364877.com | www.36166e.com | xin98886.com | 28824p.com | 69443366.com | j2368.com | 5589i.com | www.hg8880.hk | www.k27229.com | www.999966.com | www.bd2019f.com | www.c1432.com | www.9187h.com | www.120168.com | www.022gx.cc | www.guocai667.com | 69990u.com | 55991277.com | pj88pp.com | 99111tt.com | www.7777wnsr.com | www.624444d.com | www.808888f.com | www.0088hgcc.com | www.33358c.com | www.666937.com | hgw89.com | 111122.com | 1155589.com | ying58.xyz | www.zun544.com | www.vns00ss.com | www.899741.com | www.ba504.com | www.16878s.com | www.472717.com | 3983019.com | youfa560.com | 8036y.com | www.8882558.com | www.9999xx.com | www.91779c.com | www.68689z.com | www.587639.com | bwinccc.com | 4255oo.com | 6868yy.cc | www.w9603.com | www.65066cc.com | www.8582qq.com | www.918795.com | 6220xx.com | 463y8.com | jnn003.com | www.66333666.com | www.630468.com | www.3478l.cc | 76886u.com | 444000q.com | 66458e.com | www.xaanf.com | www.2283066.com | www.2875j.com | 54443v.com | 281555.com | 80878q.com | www.2323006.com | www.xpj916.com | www.cb3188.com | n62365.com | 29918.com | www.3459d.com | www.472741.com | www.11081.cc | 9895o.com | 2224001.com | www.o8867.com | www.26123jj.com | www.27776.cc | 5005h.com | jinshabet.com | www.ld4488.com | www.s32031.com | www.cpkk6.com | aa3336.com | swin6.com | www.amjsty5.com | www.3846cc.com | www.628846.com | 58898.com | P35ee.com | www.68277888.com | www.50051h.com | 6861.com | u86811.com | www.33354.com | www.886948.com | www.055973.com | 4165.com | www.y5777.com | www.984703.com | www.160913.com | 23599f.com | www.msc111.com | www.xpj8896.com | www.375736.com | yh22444.com | www.2899msc.com | www.130013.com | www.501866.com | 00774ss.com | www.r766.com | www.81608b.com | 15a34.net | qq365v.com | www.mgdc48.com | www.02022.com | 66300vip35.com | 64898e.com | www.0169c.com | www.810715.com | 9rui8888.com | www.n5522.com | www.6939r.com | 62033.com | 500000559.com | www.x32939.com | www.701361.com | 32555h.com | www.dhycp8811.com | www.yh76g.com | 3399vn77.com | www.jz977.com | www.a458.com | h2306.com | ll2649.com | www.3396877.com | www.550434.com | 22296beijin.com | www.7646.com | www.959591.com | a44.com | www.225430.com | www.87171.cc | yl6944.com | www.7494455.com | www.50024h.com | 9411ccc.com | www.16076.com | www.71233g.com | 5004ee.com | www.am1111.cc | www.52303k.com | 4340k.com | www.32126z.net | www.35918z.com | bocaiyule.cn | www.4650000.com | www.hczx4.com | 04666f.com | www.hd779.com | www.805681.com | 8547pp.com | www.4963s.com | www.csw288.com | 44hh8331.com | www.99094v.com | 6699vn77.com | www.ra8804.com | www.022hk.cc | tz22888.com | www.jj55826.com | yin6666.com | www.vns0100.com | www.5951990.com | 9964j.com | www.544618.com | www.857380.com | 7742nn.com | www.6880ww.com | 5509.com | www.457777.com | www.810702.com | 444000vvv.com | www.33959.com | n7742.com | www.hg7211m.com | www.746133.com | 0434388.com | www.x88789.com | 8569811k.com | www.668cp11.com | 56987zz.com | www.hg33711.com | www.9155c.com | afcp09.com | www.o2894.com | 30170033.com | www.63iii.com | www.137105.com | www.xpj8888.cc | www.26878q.com | x33d.vip | www.14168a.com | cp11991.com | www.2945j.com | 53166i.com | www.35441777.com | www.548477.com | www.yh1088.com | www.23636n.com | 28288u.com | www.9350.vip | 3678zzz.com | www.biying950vip.com | 0652h.com | www.tyc002.com | 44446.com | www.xhf5555.com | www.325477.com | www.k32126.cc | www.aa0090.com | 2643x.com | www.66332z.com | 878365mm.com | www.js1992.com | 23599m.com | www.4102j.com | 53166s.com | www.sha2333.com | 3405bbb.com | www.jz95566.com | 80368kk.com | www.lyjcp.cc | 7172244.com | www.wd817.com | 4052s.com | www.608499.com | 8381kk.com | www.155417.com | 700089v.com | www.yfcp315.com | ms38648ll.cc | www.89599p.com | xs9411.com | www.3066yy.com | 0485n.com | www.9464gg.com | 3559ff.com | www.6889772.com | 4182v.com | www.81678h.com | 7989h.com | www.9lbc.com | www.b3656.com | www.622989.com | www.fh6000.com | www.33112i.com | www.2005647.com | 7777wd.com | www.c32.net | 2677.com | www.7240f.com | 09780.com | www.25688p.com | www.1869k.com | www.584499.com | www.k64602.com | 082373.com | www.bscpjj.com | pjguangdong.com | www.xpj8869.com | 8977zz.com | www.37676.cc | www.vns388.com | www.187513.com | www.qq599.com | df8jj.com | www.4546600.com | hg1044.com | www.07163l.com | www.399801.com | www.089859.com | www.www-26499.com | 7736r.com | www.55676m.com | 7989w.com | www.901770.com | www.hg3058.com | 70.net | www.xj6003.com | 35qq.vip | www.938627.com | www.9949f.com | 4546119.com | www.7036dd.com | am6868.cc | www.640638.com | www.yiyao12.com | 1669a.com | www.h6640.com | 091061.com | www.196209.com | www.138cpc.com | a14666.com | www.7793e.com | www.09569m.com | 61366s.com | www.403678.com | feicai023.com | www.330175.com | www.138cpa.com | 0004116.com | www.2934f.com | www.8888888b.com | 61788.am | www.999sun.com | www.608333.com | 115505.com | www.780780g.com | 56987ee.com | P35kk.com | www.1851135.com | 168cp-z.com | www.lcw997.com | www.cc55826.com | 33382r.com | www.560723.com | www.a81e.cc | mohan2013.com | www.646959.com | www.91gwc.com | wx2277.com | www.634679.com | www.5555zh.cm | 310577.com | www.338061.com | www.55070u.com | 2455u.com | 00048j.com | www.161184.com | 1156.com | 1458m.com | www.ya2019a.com | www.330099x.com | 7720796.com | www.cbw222.com | www.019059.com | 4955b.com | www.399140.com | www.bet63f.com | 0600s.cc | 915904310.com | www.008.vip | www.yh8364.com | 9646w.com | www.901758.com | www.4568999.com | 2535a.com | 2677eee.com | www.37377u.com | www.t8003.com | ctxcpyh.com | www.88djcp.com | www.89599z.com | lt101.net | 530598.com | www.33598j.com | www.604700.com | v2351.com | 44pp8332.com | www.0883888.com | www.892099.com | 65365.com | www.202314.com | www.32031.com | www.dy4411.com | 407.com | www.607269.com | www.621301.com | www.yh3377.cc | mayait.cn | www.606694.com | www.69989b.com | www.bt258.com | 06385959.com | www.314877.com | www.98xpj98.com | www.88021ii.com | mg7899.com | vdisk.cn | www.84499k.com | www.48968.com | 8905f.com | 2698d.com | www.c9218.com | www.1851132.com | www.hg33733.com | 2214p.com | www.66621o.com | www.109337.com | www.810msc.com | 667766w.com | 1331u.com | www.621410.com | www.42070011.com | www.pujing222.com | p7890.com | 1288cc.com | www.959591.com | www.77784yh.com | www.4763666.com | 13638.com | 3434ggg.com | www.966943.com | www.40288a.com | www.427567.com | drcp666.com | 2356.com | www.570323.com | www.68993265.com | www.1389oo.com | www.56733r.com | 9068u.com | 0747zz.com | www.fcff1.com | www.6880ww.com | www.tyc855.com | 243d2.com | 6345544.com | 33oo8332.com | www.qmkl1.com | www.3846g.com | www.833099.com | www.0967111.com | k60111.com | 51335e.com | www.834918.com | www.456137.net | www.27363p.com | www.f4737.com | jindaye88.com | 727720.com | l62365.com | www.c132.vip | www.81608c.com | www.1168j.com | www.09569m.com | 2190t.com | 3568kk.com | 83086o.com | www.397411.com | www.32123n.com | www.lhg5555.com | www.xh6666.com | www.32126x.net | JS1388u.com | 4778822.com | 22pp8331.com | www.374977.com | www.9478i.com | www.i94600.com | www.tc8804.com | www.900673.com | kk4675.com | 2096u.com | 9123567.com | 13222w.com | www.330271.com | www.33clf.com | www.6939v.com | www.sha2333.com | www.bet445.com | www.333133y.com | js333044.com | 3651462.com | 68bet.com | 33888016.com | feicai0990.com | www.493381.com | www.1368u.cc | www.ya2019i.com | www.32031i.com | www.38345x.com | www.66335.com | www.438msc.com | www.gh0031.com | 229.cc | hbs481.com | 1076002.com | 1775tt.com | 50099d.com | P35gg.com | www.389844.com | www.c6883.com | www.33598l.com | www.55111122.com | www.4102h.com | www.89677v.com | www.qmc0033.com | www.870000.com | www.5888868.com | www.39695d.com | www.yh6008.com | 8290h.com | 2846o.com | 17500.cn | 4025m.com | 77606r.com | 62222x.com | 1213121.com | xj001c.com | 98345k.com | 2004871.com | 66458d.com | js648888.com | 48586.com | www.50080u.com | www.265553.com | www.501251.com | www.715699.com | www.926887.com | www.c6882.com | www.w459.com | www.w984.com | www.yi328.com | www.3479b.com | www.7793d.com | www.8816x.com | www.8499y.com | www.05881.cc | www.3416n.com | www.281877.com | www.5441v.com | www.1035f.com | www.55clf.com | www.hm3788.com | www.715777a.com | www.939562.com | www.912480.com | www.937986.com | www.862422.com | www.652631.com | www.533081.com | www.343577.com | www.118428.com | 99589j.net | 1483u.com | 0907.ws | amam8.com | ppjj00.com | 98345i.com | 4167d.com | 22883j.com | 00442007.com | 168cp-k.com | www.yh77706.com | www.v0020.com | www.9996hh.com | www.hg2282.com | www.09766.com | www.060sunbet.com | www.99113d.com | www.7225f.com | www.087j.com | www.305155.com | www.26199.com | www.960106.com | www.340911.com | 11aa8332.com | b778877.com | 2064hb.com | 3778bb.com | 33115y.com | www.mg4355888.com | www.00829c.com | www.58695.com | www.6003p.com | www.cn365a.com | www.1764x.com | www.77114n.com | www.zcwf1.com | www.357173.com | sypk10.com | 5156.com | blm877.com | 537a.cc | www.85770x.com | www.071095.com | www.458177.com | www.xpj1.net | www.7714x.com | www.777337a.com | www.097918.com | 04666n.com | bmw8088.com | 80850a.com | www.hg5538.com | www.c8888.net | www.4212t.com | www.765.me | www.5522i.cc | www.351781.com | 68963333.com | 0207893.com | 2767k.com | www.001711.com | www.hg8270.com | www.332337.com | www.66652d.com | www.581209.com | jm8.tw | 5651o.com | 37570p.com | www.88807k.com | www.249559.com | www.293853.com | www.hx6693.com | xyhd237.com | 98345r.com | 3122ll.com | www.7165502.com | www.gt111999.com | www.bet365yazhou.com | www.926730.com | xh00020.com | 713jc.com | 632910.com | www.53532.com | www.64566b.com | www.54400y.com | www.316530.com | 87621.com | 86811kk.com | www.00618z.com | www.4972j.com | www.105607.com | www.544095.com | 1985555.com | 6868269.com | www.40686f.com | www.644886.com | www.29496d.com | www.261793.com | 5651x.com | 0080i.com | www.260666.com | www.xpj13666.com | www.901173.com | 6403z.com | 2012.com | www.16297733.com | www.http://1018js.com/ | www.3005v.com | tyc5504.com | 55967q.com | www.2846a.com | www.http://09991.com | www.022c.cc | www.hg8855.com | www.374317.com | YL7999.com | pj88qq.com | www.vip22252.com | www.bwinyz06.com | www.5dwj.com | 9539t.com | 80850gg.com | www.yxlmwx.net | www.5446w.com | www.536678.com | pj1007.com | www.hg66768.com | www.dzcp3333.com | www.68682l.com | sha9904.com | t58955.com | www.1113890.com | www.vinisi08.com | www.322424.com | 56787gg.com | www.33928a08.com | www.y063801.com | www.luck887.com | 66559193.com | www.l32126.cc | www.i1432.com | www.703153.com | bwinlll.com | www.hg8662.com | www.9895t.com | www.533265.com | lh66x.com | www.20167744.com | www.hg7113.com | www.153680.com | 3559nnn.com | www.3170005.com | www.9511888.com | 444000j.com | w35151.com | www.sz2888.com | www.2632a.com | 20833d.com | www.vns998.com | www.63606b.com | www.215880.com | 6146j.com | www.260666.com | www.33598d.com | pjxizang.com | www.39728.com | www.m3410.com | www.325826.com | 88850bb.com | www.522118.com | www.60007l.com | vns7.vip | www.js69ll.cc | www.14168e.com | f2490.com | 256777w.com | www.1064f.com | www.556346.com | 88850bb.com | www.91955.com | www.hy6935.com | 3678y.com | www.yy6656.com | www.52072s.com | 3616g.com | www.tyc900.com | www.535520.com | 80850g.com | www.4107f.com | www.8582zz.com | 58588n.com | www.98699.com | www.0096788.com | 6146n.com | www.www-66000.com | www.456333.net | blm959.com | www.882589.com | www.hd8678.com | 818555.vip | www.88c07.com | www.bet73d.com | 28824v.com | www.20167744.com | www.66621l.com | 3467l.com | www.hg8835.com | www.08588p.com | 66783.com | www.303800.com | www.c760.vip | 6403p.com | www.99113y.com | www.177109.com | xpj888a.com | www.97994f.com | 5099zz.com | www.hg806.com | www.91233y.com | 998789.com | www.666089.com | www.785803.com | hwcp44.com | www.1429b1.com | 76543l.com | www.wan6668888.com | www.944990.com | 131nnn.net | www.660tk.com | www.596960.com | 6220i.com | www.8905k.com | js14f.com | www.701707.com | www.qucp7.com | pjheilongjiang.com | www.57800b.com | 0434311.com | www.76543d.com | www.18005.com | 3559vv.com | www.55060x.com | aa5443.com | www.a4737.com | www.0014o.com | wnsr8812.com | www.45598k.com | 7798aa.com | www.pk989.net | www.672766.com | 88807m.com | www.6939o.com | 5360a.com | www.w3065.com | 9902666.com | www.25288j.com | www.934680.com | 3189v.com | www.4331a.com | ahg0088.com | www.2yhyh.com | 68963333.com | www.9a003.com | www.423552.com | www.yh77702.com | www.00840w.com | 61323399.com | www.8905g.com | blr365365.com | www.b456x.com | tt5443.com | www.js6767g.com | www.511079.com | www.0222js.com | www.8499y.com | 704.com | www.59899a.com |